针灸可以治精神病？

Flier-Mate

我是从隔壁板块来的。我曾经接受过针灸医治我的精神病，到最后的那位医师因为使用过度，结果扎针的头顶部位出血而终告一段落了。


想问针灸可以是治疗精神病的另类疗法吗(Complement/Alternate Therapy)？

ant79

针灸是可以治疗某些精神病。
癫狂之类的，因为病人不能配合，所以不行。
除此之外，如精神衰弱，忧郁症，焦虑症等都有帮助。

Flier-Mate

回复 2# ant79


    谢谢你的答复。我了解得不多。那是几年前的事了。

通常精神科医生会认同针灸吗？（我没有问过我的主治医生，都是自己去找中医就诊的。）

ant79

回复 3# Flier-Mate


    通常西医不是很认同，认同的知识少数。
请问你是那方面的问题？忧郁症？焦虑症？

Flier-Mate

回复 4# ant79


    原来只是少数。

我得了精神分裂症。请问有效吗？忘了以前做针灸的时候有没有见效。

ant79

回复 5# Flier-Mate


   hmm.... 这个比较困难，如果你愿意，可以尝试看看~但是得花时间治疗。

Flier-Mate

回复 6# ant79


    谢谢！相信治疗精神分裂症的Associative symptoms会有帮助，因为也是情绪/焦虑等问题。

ant79

回复 7# Flier-Mate


   嗯~不过，得有耐心治疗。

tianhua1978

回复 1# Flier-Mate


    针灸有帮助。我父亲曾治疗好过几例的精神分裂症的病人，就是用的针灸和中药。

华侨

回复  ant79


    原来只是少数。

我得了精神分裂症。请问有效吗？忘了以前做针灸的时候有没有见效 ...
Flier-Mate 发表于 10-6-2011 08:50 AM

心病得靠心药医!
修好心性, 养足精神就能冶好精神分裂症!

whohiccup

我得了精神分裂症。
Flier-Mate 发表于 10-6-2011 08:50

真是可怜。多半跟前世有关。

设法了结（不是了解）你前世欠的，然后在弥补今世的，慢慢(三到五年)有起色。

很玄妙的... ...

happy_rong

我也是得了精神分裂症，我不想天天吃药，因为口很干想吐，希望有中医的治疗，或是针灸。

bubbletea12321

针灸應可提高患者生活質素及服藥量/副作用：
“There are positive indications for improvements in
quality of life, symptoms of schizophrenia and side effects of
anti-psychotic medication”
（http://www.ejom.co.uk/pdf/Vol6.5-Ronan.pdf）

“60 schizophrenia patients were treated with electro-acupuncture and chlorpromazine therapy in comparison with chlorpromazine therapy alone, 30 patients for each group, and their curative effects evaluated according to the brief psychiatric rating scale (BPRS).

The result showed the total curative effects of the two groups were similar. However, the marked effects appeared earlier in combined therapy than that of using chlorpromazine alone, less chlorpromazine was needed, hence displayed fewer side-effects.”
（http://www.acupuncture.com/research/schizo.htm）

在中國有成功的例子：
“In China, acupuncture is often used to treat schizophrenia, and several successful trials have been reported (Kane & Di Scipio 1979, Shi & Tan 1986)：

Kane J, Di Scipio W 1979 Acupuncture treatment of schizophrenia: report on three cases. American Journal of Psychiatry 136:297-302. RESULTS: In a 9-week study of three schizophrenics, two patients responded positively to true acupuncture treatment and negatively to “sham” treatment and a third patient showed no significant response to treatment.

Shi Z, Tan M 1986 An analysis of the therapeutic effect of acupuncture treatment in 500 cases of schizophrenia. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 6:99-104. RESULTS: “Cure” in 275 patients, no help in 58 patients and varying imrpovement in the rest In a follow-up of 194 patients, 63 relapsed within 2 years. Patients wit ha history of less than 1 year showed a more favorable response, but even a 10-year history did not prevent nine patients from responding favorably.

Zhang M 1988 Treatment of 296 cases of hallucination with scalp-acupuncture. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 8:193-194. RESULTS: Of 296 cases of hallucination, 292 had schizophrenia. RESULTS: 10 daily sessions with the needles retained between 1 and 3 hours resulted in a 70% “cure” rate after 10-20 treatments“
（http://eastwestacupuncture.net/psych.htm）