[实况] 美国偶像 AMERICAN IDOL VII (禁止spoiler!!!)

justinlp

原帖由 chowsc86 于 9-4-2008 12:52 AM 发表

真的变成Arch angel了？。。。

musicloverboy88

看了十秒钟MC在IGB的演唱。有点失望下。

http://www.dailymotion.com/video ... ly-like-a-bir_music

要看的话，就按；不要的话，就别按。

chowsc86

原帖由 justinlp 于 9-4-2008 12:56 AM 发表


真的变成Arch angel了？。。。

恶到

chowsc86

david a明天还唱Angels

chowsc86

justinlp

原帖由 chowsc86 于 9-4-2008 01:56 AM 发表

恶到

所以我说我不爽的是他的fan。。。什么都太过over了。。
反胃。。

chowsc86

Name : Michael Johns
Song Title : Dream On
Judges Thoughts : (R) It had some pitch problems but I thought it was a good song choice. It was ok. (P) I think it was a perfect song. You sound as good as you look. You were unbelievable. (S) I thought it was a very good performance. I am slightly with Randy. I don’t like it when you do an impersonation of a rock star.




Name : Syesha Mercado
Song Title : I Believe
Judges Thoughts : (R) I give you credit. Another tiger this week. It was ok, just ok. I felt no connection with you. (P) Not many people can take on songs like that. You flipped it and made it all your own. I think it was one of your most shining nights. (S) Technically you sang it very well. It lacked that big weight of emotion that I got when Fantasia sang it. I want to find out what you are all about.




Name : Jason Castro
Song Title : Somewhere Over The Rainbow
Judges Thoughts : (R) Dude Jason Castro is back in the hunt. That was molten hot. (P) You have the most difintive sound with the guitar. You did a great job. (S) Fantastic.




Name : Kristy Lee Cook
Song Title : Anyway
Judges Thoughts : (R) A couple of little pitch problems but really good. (P) I think you outdid yourself. This was your best by far. Excellent. (S) I thought you were very very good indeed. Tonight you look like a star. It was a smart choice of song.




Name : David Cook
Song Title : Innocent
Judges Thoughts : (R) I am a huge fan of yours but I am not sure this was one of your strongest weeks. (P) You are so well defined as being the whole package. (S) I didn’t like this performance very much. I didn’t like the white jacket. Originality, choice of song and something we will remember in 2 or 3 days and it wasn’t anywhere near as good as the last 2 weeks.



Name : Carly Smithson
Song Title : The Show Must Go On
Judges Thoughts : (R) Started out good, a little pitchy in the middle and ended up ok. Only ok for me. (P) Your voice as always is pretty perfect, I just didn’t feel the connection. (S) You look good. I thought it was an unusual choice of song. You over sang it. It came over as an angry performance. You might be in a bit of trouble after tonight.




Name : David Archuleta
Song Title : Angels
Judges Thoughts : (R) Thats the David that I love. That was the hottest moment of the season. (P) That sums it up for me, fantastic. (S) Best song choice of the night so far. I am not going to say it was your best vocal though. It was a bit nasally. You will sail through to the next round.




Name : Brooke White
Song Title : You’ve Got a Friend
Judges Thoughts : (R) For me I don’t think it was your best performance. It was ok. (P) Perfect way to close the evening. (S) A pleasant walk in the park. It was nice. Was it original, no.

chowsc86

这里可以先看

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=onefjkdxfFs

chowsc86

michael - 刚开始觉得还不错，但后面part就
jason - 有那么好咩，没感觉
kristy lee cook - 想她走的人又要失望了，我觉得还蛮不错的
brooke - 平平淡淡，不过期待studio版本
carly - 看起来漂亮了很多，虽然肚子还是很明显，我觉得表现并没有很差哦
david a - randy:That was the hottest moment of the season 是不错但是没有那么好plz
syesha - 我觉得是全场最佳，但是大家似乎都活在fantasia的版本下
david cook - 显露出低音的弱点，失色了

吃饭

原帖由 chowsc86 于 9-4-2008 12:52 AM 发表

恶...虾米来...........

吃饭

原帖由 chowsc86 于 9-4-2008 08:08 AM 发表


http://i114.photobucket.com/albums/n271/chowsc86/l_4916ea ...

shasha很‘伟大‘。。。现在才发觉到。。。

musicloverboy88

原帖由 吃饭 于 9-4-2008 10:43 AM 发表


shasha很‘伟大‘。。。现在才发觉到。。。

想法跟你一样。

justinlp

有没有想过KKKristy lee cook会多呆一个星期？。。

小鸟的鸟

haha...Mimi將在下星期的ＡＩ演唱ＢＹＥ ＢＹＥ

chowsc86

原帖由 justinlp 于 9-4-2008 11:46 AM 发表
有没有想过KKKristy lee cook会多呆一个星期？。。

去看dialidol

原帖由 吃饭 于 9-4-2008 10:41 AM 发表


恶...虾米来...........

david a迷的幻想

santa_fe

原帖由 justinlp 于 9-4-2008 12:56 AM 发表
真的变成Arch angel了？。。。

需要醬meh。。。   
原來現在還流行這種百分百好男孩的

teong1984

原帖由 justinlp 于 9-4-2008 11:46 AM 发表
有没有想过KKKristy lee cook会多呆一个星期？。。

其实她并不差。

teong1984

Carly - 渐渐失色了。。。选错歌，高音部分小走音，对于要求完美演唱的她肯定很失望。

Kristy - 一次比一次好。这次真的像star了。

Syesha - 选错歌了。评判已经先入为主，唱这首歌很难得到好评。她需要凸现自己的charisma，这是她缺乏的。可能她本身是演员，所以她不会在荧幕前呈现原始的她。

Michael - 开始真的很好。最后不懂他选择这样的方式做结尾。

Jason - 非常original的版本。听显了原版。。。很好！虽然曲调变得比较轻快，感动依然有。

David Cook - 其实这首歌非常好听，很有意思。觉得他很疲惫。低音必须改进。唱得很吃力。

David Archuleta - 他在中学时期曾经演唱过，那时的版本更好。非常original， 不同于原版，不过Robbie的版本更加经典。他很轻易成为当晚的top 3。

Brooke White - 没有亮点。

Chewwy

觉得今晚 Micheal， Syesha & David 唱到不错下的咯。。。都很有感觉。。。

Carly, Brooke 跟 Jason 就没这么好。。。
很显jason的唱法了。。。都是一样的听了都要睡觉。。。。

justinlp

原帖由 teong1984 于 9-4-2008 07:21 PM 发表


其实她并不差。

没说她差。。。只是她给的结果蛮意外的。。。

难得我要这样排今晚的top 3

Kristy, David A, Syesha。。。
（Syesha唱得不差啊，唱功简直是8人之上。。。Fantasia的很好听咩？。。鸭子叫酱)


Bottom 3
David C, Brooke, Carly
我今晚的的Bottom3竟然包括了我的2位最爱（绝对不包括Carly。。）



不过如果这星期有赶人回家的话。。。那人应该还是Syesha。。
除非这星期有shocking elimination。。就是我那bottom3里的其中一个回家。。。
那个人最好是Carly。。。想她滚蛋很久廖。。

[ 本帖最后由 justinlp 于 9-4-2008 09:37 PM 编辑 ]