Do W. D. Gann’s trading techniques really work?

lcchong

We have came across a lot of excellent marketing, selling and presentation that promoting Gann’s trading techniques. For instance,


In trading world, we should open for any good idea, but should remain skeptical, especially those things that sound too good to be true. Thus, I do further research on W. D. Gann trading techniques. I finally found some materials that actually contradict with what the promoters promoting.



Source: Trading for a living: psychology, trading tactics, money management By Alexander Elder




Source: The Right Stock at the Right Time: Prospering in the Coming Good Years by Larry R. Williams

If Gann’s son himself also clarified that his father couldn’t make a living by his own trading techniques, I am pretty sure Gann’s trading techniques most likely not working.

My opinion worth nothing, but I believe Gann's son and Larry William

风满楼

最近来了很多“ang mor”
还以为进了英语论坛，这里不是禁止英文写贴的吗？

“Are W. D. Gann’s trading techniques really work?”
订正：Do W. D. Gann’s trading techniques really work?

lcchong

懒惰翻译. 看回原著好一点

雷克斯R

Gann是很多trader的mentor

lcchong

回复 4# 雷克斯R


这个就是所谓的那些GURU. 当一个东西几乎完美, 谨慎一点.

我们公开接受任何新的东西, 但是我们必须抱着实事求是的精神

雷克斯R

回复 5# lcchong


    不盲目跟從就對了吧

mancai

拜托至少寫些中文，這樣扣下去你又要register new ID了

ctr1129

要试过才知道的！ 请问有谁试过他的技巧吗？ 有的话就跟大家分享一下咯！ 不过我试过很多大师级的所谓“大师”都是很。。。。。。

北风沙

酱快变乞丐了

风满楼

我一直百思不得其解
明明华语表达得更好，却一直坚持用表达得很烂的英语来写贴，宁愿被扣分贬为乞丐
这不针对楼主个人，发现这个论坛很多这样的人
为什么会有这种奇怪的现象？
讲英文真的能抬高自己吗？